top of page
Warm brown-toned blurred background, possibly an office desk setting, Focused Mental Education logo overlay
Focused Mental Education
Font

Psychological Injury Claims: Why Prevention Matters More

Nov 11
8 min read

Psychological injury claims are now the most expensive and slowest to resolve of all serious workplace injuries in Australia, and governments are responding in two very different ways. Queensland has joined NSW in tightening who can claim, while more than 100 organisations met in Melbourne this week to push for a $1.25 billion national investment in preventing mental illness before it starts. Sitting between the two is a quiet problem: most workers never use the support their employer already pays for. For managers and organisations, the message from this fortnight's news is consistent. Narrowing the claims gate does not remove the harm or your legal duty to prevent it. Early, skilled, human support does.

At a glance

  • Serious psychological injury claims have risen 169% in a decade to about 17,900 in 2024-25, with a median payout of $68,600 and an average of 34.8 weeks off work (Safe Work Australia figures, cited 10 November 2026).

  • Queensland's Industrial Relations and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 would require work to be "the major significant contributing factor" for a psychological injury claim. Public hearings run on 12 and 13 November, with the committee due to report on 27 November.

  • Only 5 to 6% of employees with access to an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) use it, falling to around 2% in retail, construction and manufacturing.

  • More than 100 organisations met at the Prevention Convention in Melbourne on 10 November to build a $1.25 billion prevention plan, to be released on 23 November.

  • A Fire and Rescue NSW trial found that four hours of mental health training for managers returned about $10 for every $1 spent.

Psychological injury claims: the numbers employers cannot ignore

New figures circulated this week by the Employee Assistance Professional Association of Australasia (EAPAA), drawing on Safe Work Australia's Key Work Health and Safety Statistics, show how sharply the picture has shifted. Serious psychological injury claims rose 169% over the past decade to about 17,900 in 2024-25 and now make up 12.2% of all serious workers' compensation claims.

The cost per claim is what stands out. The median payout for a psychological injury is $68,600, roughly four times that of other serious claims, and affected workers typically spend 34.8 weeks away from work, about five times longer than for other injuries.

NSW tells the same story. EML's Mental Health Insights Report 2026, published on 30 October, notes that psychological claims make up 12% of NSW workers' compensation claims but 38% of total costs. The same report found only 29% of workers would lodge a claim if work seriously harmed their mental health, which suggests the claims data shows only part of the harm actually happening in workplaces.

Why it matters: A psychological injury claim is usually the end of a long chain of missed signals: rising workload, conflict, poor support, a person quietly struggling. By the time a claim is lodged, the person has often been unwell for months. Every week of earlier intervention is good for the worker and costs the organisation far less than 34.8 weeks of lost time.

Queensland moves to tighten its claims test

On 14 October, Deputy Premier and Industrial Relations Minister Jarrod Bleijie introduced the Industrial Relations and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 into the Queensland Parliament. Under clause 121, employment would need to be "the major significant contributing factor" for a psychological or psychiatric injury, rather than the current "a significant contributing factor". The same test would apply to aggravations of existing conditions.

The Bill also widens the "reasonable management action" exclusion. It expressly covers investigations into alleged misconduct and states that minor errors or omissions would not, of themselves, make management action unreasonable. The time to seek review of an insurer's decision would fall from three months to 20 business days, and the maximum penalty for fraud would double from five to ten years' imprisonment.

The context is cost pressure. WorkCover Queensland, which insures about 186,000 businesses, accepted 4,110 primary mental injury claims in 2025-26. They accounted for 16% of statutory payments, or $334 million. The government has warned premiums could rise 26% over five years without reform. Business Chamber Queensland chief executive Heidi Cooper welcomed the changes, while workers' lawyers have warned they could make support harder to reach for some injured workers. The State Development, Infrastructure and Works Committee holds public hearings on 12 and 13 November and is due to report on 27 November.

Why it matters: Queensland follows NSW, which tightened eligibility for psychological injury claims from 1 July 2026. But a higher bar for compensation does not lower the bar for safety. Under work health and safety laws, every employer must still identify and control psychosocial hazards such as excessive workload, poor support and workplace conflict, and in NSW SafeWork inspectors are actively checking (see our October 2026 news update), while Safe Work Australia's review of the model laws points to stronger psychosocial duties ahead (see WHS Laws Review: What It Means for Mental Health at Work). Fewer accepted claims could simply mean more people working while unwell.

The support most workers never use

Most medium and large Australian organisations fund an EAP, offering free and confidential short-term counselling. Yet industry benchmarking cited by EAPAA puts utilisation at just 5 to 6% of eligible employees. In retail, construction and manufacturing it can be as low as 2%, while finance and government reach 9 to 10%.

EAPAA President Mary Talbot put the problem simply: "The gap now is that staff either don't know it's there, don't trust it's confidential, or think it's only for a crisis."

EML's research points the same way. Two in five workers took at least one day off for their mental health in the past year, but only about one in four told their employer the real reason. Silence, not a lack of services, is often the barrier.

Why it matters: An EAP sitting unused on the intranet is not a control measure. People are far more likely to reach out when someone they trust notices the change in them, starts a calm conversation and walks them through the options. That is exactly what Mental Health First Aid trains people to do, and it is why trained staff and managers make existing supports work harder.

A $1.25 billion push to prevent mental illness

On Tuesday 10 November, more than 100 organisations gathered at the Prevention Convention in Melbourne, led by Prevention United with support from Spark Studios and Medibank Group. Participants include Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Beyond Blue, Black Dog Institute, Mental Health Australia, UNICEF, VicHealth, Movember and Smiling Mind.

Their goal is a single, coordinated proposal for a $1.25 billion investment in prevention, to be put to the Federal Government ahead of the May 2027 Budget. It sits within the 5% for Prevention campaign, which calls for at least 5% of national mental health spending to go to evidence-based prevention. According to the Wellbeing and Prevention Coalition in Mental Health, less than 1% currently does. Half of all mental illness begins by age 14.

The convention is weighing four priority areas: supporting children and families in the early years and adolescence, community-led prevention, the workforce and data needed to know what works, and a national campaign to change how Australians think about prevention. The national plan will be released on Monday 23 November, and free online screenings of the documentary Raising Superheroes run from 19 to 25 November.

Why it matters: Australia spends most of its mental health budget once people are already unwell. Shifting even a few cents in each dollar towards prevention, in schools, communities and workplaces, would ease pressure on hospitals, the NDIS and the claims systems described above. Workplaces are one of the few places where most adults can be reached every week, which makes them a natural part of any prevention plan.

What works: skilled managers and early conversations

There is good evidence that relatively small investments in people skills pay off. In a trial reported in EML's 2026 report, Fire and Rescue NSW gave managers four hours of mental health training. It was associated with 6.45 fewer hours of work-related sickness absence per employee over six months, and returned about $10 for every dollar spent.

Managers taking part in a workplace mental health training session in a bright Australian meeting room

As EML's Daniel Walton noted, awareness of workplace mental health is high, but "it is not translating into meaningful employer action". Training is one of the most practical ways to close that gap, because it turns good intentions into a skill a manager can use on a Tuesday afternoon.

Why it matters: Managers are usually the first to see a change in someone's behaviour, attendance or mood. When they know how to start the conversation, listen without judgement and point the person to the right help, problems are picked up weeks or months before they become a claim.

What it means for you

Individuals and families

  • If you have access to an EAP through your own or a family member's employer, find the number now, not when you are in crisis. It is confidential and you can use it for grief, stress, relationship or work worries.

  • If you notice someone close to you withdrawing, taking more days off or seeming flat, ask how they are going and listen. You do not need to have the answers.

  • Learning basic skills through Standard Mental Health First Aid or Youth Mental Health First Aid can give you the confidence to help.

Managers and team leaders

  • Talk about your EAP regularly and explain clearly that it is confidential and not only for emergencies.

  • Watch for early signs such as changes in mood, attendance, workload or relationships, and check in early rather than waiting for a formal process.

  • Make sure management actions, including performance and misconduct processes, are fair, well documented and delivered with care. That protects both the person and the organisation.

Organisations

  • Treat tighter claims laws as a reason to strengthen prevention, not relax it. Your work health and safety duty to manage psychosocial hazards has not changed.

  • Run a psychosocial risk assessment covering workload, role clarity, support, conflict and change. Our psychosocial hazards consultancy can help you identify and control risks and document your approach.

  • Build a network of trained people across shifts and sites through workplace Mental Health First Aid training, so help is never far away.

  • Offer accessible professional support, including counselling, alongside your EAP.

How Focused Mental Education can help

Focused Mental Education delivers accredited Mental Health First Aid training, psychosocial hazard consultancy, counselling and NDIS supports across Australia. Whether you want to train your managers, assess your psychosocial risks or support a team member who is struggling, we can tailor a program to your workplace. Explore our courses, call us on (02) 8044 3365 or email info@fme.com.au. You can find more articles in our Knowledge Hub.

Need support now?

If this article has raised concerns for you or someone you know, support is available 24/7. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14, the Suicide Call Back Service on 1300 659 467 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636. If life is in danger, call 000.

Sources

  1. Mirage News (release for EAPAA), "Most Employees Skip Employer-Funded Mental Health Support", 10 November 2026. miragenews.com

  2. Insurance Business Australia, "Just 29% would claim for work-related mental harm, EML finds", 30 October 2026. insurancebusinessmag.com

  3. McCullough Robertson, "Queensland workers' compensation reforms: what employers and insurers need to know", 21 October 2026. mccullough.com.au

  4. Redland City Bulletin, report on Queensland workers' compensation reforms, 8 November 2026. redlandbaysidenews.com.au

  5. Mirage News (release for Prevention United), "100+ Groups Unite for $1.25B Mental Illness Prevention Push", 10 November 2026. miragenews.com

  6. Focused Mental Education, "Mental Health News Australia: October 2026 Update", 28 October 2026. fme.com.au

bottom of page